< The Lord of Celebrity Smut | Main | The Office Jerk >

Who Says All Gay Men Are Stylish?

The idea that all homosexuals are fashionable is bull—just look at all the friends of Dorothy who dress like they're still in Kansas. Tell us what you think about the myth of gay style below.

-By Katherine Wheelock
-Photograph by Sasha Bezzubov


De0607ffbg011

According to a perception that clings to popular culture like a sparkly barnacle, a visit to a predominantly gay neighborhood should yield style enlightenment. Going to the West Side enclave of Chelsea in New York should be like strolling the via Montenapoleone, in Milan. Fashion-challenged men and women should flock to these places and take notes.

Tracing the roots of this myth is easy. The Stylish Gay Man is at least as old as the Magical Negro, and older than the Nerdy Asian. Since time began, homosexuality has been associated with aesthetic acumen. It's a reasonable generalization—one that Edward II, Quentin Crisp, Liberace, and others did little to weaken, and one that understandably sashayed into the late 20th century and the early 21st; most of the openly gay men American society first accepted as public figures were clothing designers.

"This idea comes from how awareness of homosexuals grew over the last 40 or 50 years," says designer Isaac Mizrahi. "To someone who only knew of three gay people, it looked like all gay men were stylish."

In movies and on TV in the eighties and nineties, gay sidekicks gave sartorial and grooming advice to their messy-haired, mannish girlfriends. The Verdis and the Cojocarus of the world emerged in their wake, and on Queer Eye for the Straight Guy, Carson Kressley and company began gussying up men. As long as the tip was offered with a cock of the hip and a Mary Lou Retton grin, it was fabulous.

"The conventional wisdom has always been that effeminate men were concerned with style and appearance," says Simon Doonan, fashion pundit and creative director at Barneys New York. "If a movie script called for a character to be fluffy or superficial, they made him a fashion designer. This gave rise to the erroneous idea that all gay men are fashion-obsessed."

But even now that the confetti from the gay-makeover party has settled, the myth of the Stylish Gay Man persists. William Sledd, a 23-year-old Gap manager from Paducah, Kentucky, just signed a deal with Bravo to do an online, critic-at-large—style show based on his video blog, "Ask a Gay Man." This spring it blew up as the fourth-most-subscribed-to video blog on YouTube. Sledd has a side-swept haircut like Clay Aiken and often wears a tight argyle sweater or a slogan T-shirt. He says things like "What's up with all the black? I don't think there are enough pink ninjas in the world." He's entertaining. But what makes him a style expert—besides the fact that he's gay?

"Schooling and exposure determine your ability to say what looks good and what doesn't look good, not your sexual preference," Mizrahi says. "It's like saying all black people have rhythm."

And as a walk through Chelsea demonstrates—in the spring, it's often a visual smorgasbord of pink polo shirts skimming potbellies, patch-bedecked denim jackets, and silvery sneakers worn with an 11-year-old girl's naive enthusiasm—the idea that homosexual males have more style sense than any other category of human beings is patently untrue. If you were picking teams, kickball-at-recess-style, for a fashion championship, who would you call first dibs on? Lance Bass, George Clooney, Alan Cumming, Jay-Z, Rufus Wainwright, or Brad Pitt?

Take your time.

Gay men, unlike supermodels and rock stars, have no more knack for looking good in pretty much anything than the rest of us. And while there might be (just barely) fewer gay rumors circulating about the painstakingly groomed, French-cuffed Ryan Seacrest than there are about the black-T-shirt-clad Simon Cowell, it's hardly risky for a straight man to demonstrate an appreciation for fashion these days. The Stylish Gay Man's days may be numbered. And when he dies, the playing field will be leveled. Entertainment-show hosts and best-dressed-list compilers will stop treating straight men who simply combed their hair and put on a well-cut suit as if they were paraplegics who just completed an Ironman. And the average gay man, saddled with unrealistic expectations for his personal presentation, will breathe a sigh of relief.

"There have been so many times when I wished I was a lesbian and didn't have to care about what I wore," says Michael Macko, vice president of men's fashion at Saks Fifth Avenue. "Why can't I put on dirty sweat pants, a pair of Birkenstocks, a flannel shirt, and think, Which baseball cap will I wear today? It must be nice to buy all your clothes at outlet stores."


Comments

Who do you think dresses these 'straight' men? Gay guys. what a really dumb article. I'm being nice btw. Did you really get paid to write this swill?

ummm, you can be straight and fashionable without any gay man's help. goodbye.

Its like Details, if my straight friends dont see women in bold poses they read all about fashion in 30 seconds. And I really love Details.

I think that its a complete myth. A lot of gay guys are really flamboyant dressers. Some of them wear prada and gucci but thats just label whoring. There are a lot more straight men with much more style. I know more straight men that know more about mens fashion and style than I know gay men. And being a student at GW and NYU, I know and have met a lot of gay guys. If you ever join the forums such as www.styleforum.com, superfuture, or aaac... you will realize that it has a lot of men that love fashion and clothing but arent gay. Gay men loving and knowing a lot about clothing is a myth. The same goes for women. A lot of them dont kown how to dress well. Since poeple associate gays with women I guess thats where it comes from...

This article lacks diversity. It portrays a stereotyped vision about gay men as if all are flamboyant, style concerned people. That is definetely not the real word. Gay men should have been interviewed to give their point of view about this subject.

International Male and Carson from that show is evidence that not all gay men are stylish.

It's like saying all black guys have rythm.

Why would you believe this obvious myth to be true in the first place. No group of people are all the same to begin with. This article should have never been published. It makes me disappointed in Details...

Well, this is my opinion, as if it matters. I am a heterosexual male who cares about style. I constantly have people ask me if I am gay or if I'm bi just because I have a good sense of style. I like this article because if it reaches the right people, they will understand that you don't have to be homosexual to dress nice. Stereotypes in themselves should not be relied on to give accurate information. With that being said, I am also one of those african americans priveleged enough to have rythm... Go figure huh?

I understand the point behind this article; encouraging heterosexual men to be proud of their own interests in style. However, this article creates as much myth as it exposes.

It plays off of stereotypes without really exposing enough angles to make any discoveries. Not all gay men dress well, it's true. Not all fashion designers are gay. And heterosexual men are often seen as dressing well all the time. So what? Everyone knows stereotypes are only a generalization. Itıs an observation.
So this article tried to explain from a heterosexual point of view where this stereotype comes from and how it affects us. But I think the source of this stereotype is much deeper and multifaceted than three designers.

All gay men want to feel wanted, just like any other person. Looking good is the most immediate way to achieve this. It is also part of Gay culture as much as rhythm is part of African American culture. Itıs part of our culture because we take pride in continuing the practice. It may come from the perception of the majority pressed onto the minority and then upheld as you suggested. But I feel itıs more to do with general human nature and contemporary western culture.

I hardly know one gay man who does not express himself in some way aesthetically or artistically, be it visual art, fashion, interior design, or culinary arts, gay men obsess over aesthetics and are very proud of their practices. Gay men are proud of beautification in American culture as much as African Americans are proud of their role in Western music.

Letıs stop for a second to speak about what it means to have style. Is it cleanliness? Is it a name brand? Is it the cost? Is it was a fashion magazine says to buy? Is it originality? Honestly who can say who is dressed well and who is not? Everyone has different taste. Good style is too relative to even label and far too diverse to press onto any demography.

Gay men are very an open or even rebellious people. They are tested endlessly by culture during their discovery and acceptance of a homosexual nature and lifestyle. More than any other group of people they are questioned for being who they are. This makes them very expressive and original people. They have more practice listening to themselves, at least the ones living their life under the gay label.

The honest truth is gay men are not afraid to dress different or create something new out of what already exists. This is what fashion is; what's trendy and what WILL be trendy. Fashion is telling people how to live. Gay men have no apprehension to try newly introduced fashion or going one step further and creating new ways to wear things. Gay men can be a part of this because they already have gone through so much rejection to be who they are that if they don't live by their own rules they don't exist. Fashion is not scary to gay men.

I guess Iım saying there are many ideas out there to why straight men should not be fashionable than there are to why other kinds of people are fashionable. Heterosexual men do not have the same tests growing up. No one questions their sexuality. They face other obstacles. One I can point out is "measuring up." This often can include conformist behaviors and more importantly a fear of sticking out in the wrong way (like being gay). So just as much as straight men can't cry they can't wear silk neck scarves or white loafers. If they express themselves in a non conformist way people question their sanity or sexuality.

Now I just committed a grave error in outlining such a stereotype. Also made the mistake of neglecting all the other reasons gay men dress well (vanity, pride, cleanliness, sex appeal and attraction, rebelling gender roles, learned behavior, elitist behavior, and their own conformist behavior within gay culture among many others). But stereotypes are in the human collection and that is why we have this conversation in the first place. People want to understand and label everything. The world is less scary when we do. However making this world less scary is not as simple as a label. Itıs a quick fix, soon to be disputed and ultimately never answered. The label for you makes things scary for me if I canıt be who I am because of it. We donıt need the label. Fashion and gender roles will continue to change in the future just as it has in the past. In short, this article should be less about explaining the relevance of fashion to sexual orientation and more about encouraging all men to just dress how they want. Just be yourself.

I think the article has a point, because it's real that if straight men dress stylish people might think they're gay, but honestly I believe that style has nothing to do with your sex.

The article is well-researched and conveying an intelligent idea (I didn't read it entirely-but givin the writer the ben of doubt)-that it's lamo to say that stylish means gay. In the U.S. perhaps it is a safe generalization but that is ethnocentric so let's not.

I've know gay men who were/are fashion tradegies and straights who are stylish, and not to mention label-whoring which has no class whatsoever. Being a fashion victim is OK if you are not lemming/sheeping whatever Details feeds you to make you feel like you feel like you are in the know. That aside, I'm a crossover in that I'm gay, but I wear fleece regularly.

nice blog

click to post a comment >
join now: post a comment close reglite module
To post a comment, simply fill in the fields below and click "submit comment." To get full access to Men.Style.com's special features & community, join now >
JOIN NOW:POST A COMMENT
All fields required.








Please send occasional e-mail updates about new features and special offers from Men.Style.com
Yes   No


I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its User Agreement and Privacy Policy

submit
sign in: post a comment close sign in and comment module
To post a comment, simply enter your comment with username and password and click "Submit Comment." Not a member? join now >
  • Comment is required.

  • We're sorry, but we could not accept your request. Please try resubmitting your information.
    SIGN IN: POST A COMMENT
    remember me next time

    submit
    not a member click to join now
    already a member click to sign in now
    click here to close