< Another Bad Diet Coming Your Way | Main | Beyond bubbles >

The Blind Taster

I wish to declare myself the greatest blind taster on earth.

In a very specialized way.

Blind tasting, as wine drinkers know, consists of identifying a wine without seeing the label or, for that matter, the bottle, which can give away a lot by its shape.

I play this game often. It's amusing, and it requires the taster to think a lot about wine. It's also challenging. The other day I was poured a glass of a dark red wine and asked, as usual, to identify it.

Generally, I would start with trying to guess the grape, then the country of origin, then perhaps the year. In the unlikely event I would get all of those right, I might try for more obscure characteristics, like the region or even the winery.

In this case, I knew precisely what the wine was.

"About $60," I said.

I was real close.

When you think about it, that's all that counts in wine these days. We want to know how much it costs. The taster who can guess that must be considered a superb oenophile. Yet I don't believe any of those fanciful degrees that wine geeks seek, like Master Sommelier or Master of Wine, requires expertise in this matter.

I now consider myself Master of Price.

The wine I tasted was a California Cabernet Sauvignon, the 2001 Terra Valentine Wurtele Vineyard. To be honest, I don't believe I can guess the price of anything except a Cabernet or a Chardonnay—these varietals aren't particularly subtle and they tend to go up in cost in direct proportion to richness, oakiness and depth of flavor. They're very straightforward.

The Terra Valentine had plenty of wood, and an unusual combination of both plentiful acidity and soft tannins. The pleasure was immediate but limited, a little rustic. I was pretty sure it wasn't going to open up, become more complex, or age particularly well. It was, however, quite forceful, as an about-$60 wine should be.

I liked it. Had I been scoring it by the more common 100-point scale, I would have given it an 89.

I looked it up on the Wine Spectator, where it was praised for its intensity and brawniness but criticized for "a cheesy, dry character" and awarded a very mediocre 85. Oh, well. I never said I was the world's best at anything except price.

Comments

click to post a comment >
join now: post a comment close reglite module
To post a comment, simply fill in the fields below and click "submit comment." To get full access to Men.Style.com's special features & community, join now >
JOIN NOW:POST A COMMENT
All fields required.








Please send occasional e-mail updates about new features and special offers from Men.Style.com
Yes   No


I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its User Agreement and Privacy Policy

submit
sign in: post a comment close sign in and comment module
To post a comment, simply enter your comment with username and password and click "Submit Comment." Not a member? join now >
  • Comment is required.

  • We're sorry, but we could not accept your request. Please try resubmitting your information.
    SIGN IN: POST A COMMENT
    remember me next time

    submit
    not a member click to join now
    already a member click to sign in now
    click here to close
    With HP wireless printers,
    you could have printed this
    article from your couch.
    Live Wirelessly, Print Wirelessly.
    SUBMIT